Home | Live Now! | Try it Now
The Scouting Report: Afghanistan and Pakistan
 
12:30
John Ward Anderson -  Greetings everybody. I’m John Anderson, a senior editor at POLITICO, and I’ll be moderating today’s chat with Brookings foreign policy fellow Vanda Felbab-Brown. She’s an expert on illicit economies, counter-narcotics strategies, US foreign policy, Afghanistan and a range of other issues, and she also teaches at Georgetown University’s School of Foreign Service.

By way of background, I first travelled to Pakistan and Afghanistan about 17 years ago and made dozens of return trips over the years – the most recent to Afghanistan in the fall of 2007 and to Pakistan in early 2008 following the assassination of Benazir Bhutto. So I have more than a passing interest, and I’m looking forward to what Vanda has to say.

As usual, I’m grabbing the right to ask the first question. Vanda, there’s a meeting scheduled this afternoon between Obama, Afghan President Hamid Karzai and Pakistani President Asif Ali Zardari. There is so much distrust and resentment between Afghanistan and Pakistan -- is there really any chance they can set aside their difference and distrust to jointly tackle the shared threats they both face from Islamic radicals – both Taliban and al-Qaeda -- in their border region? Color me skeptical.

12:30
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  Hi John and everyone!
12:31
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  Changing the dynamics between the two countries and its leaders will not be easy. Moreover, the level of distrust has expanded to the trilateral relationship -- there is a major trust deficit between Pakistan and the US and also the relationship between the new US administration and Kabul has not been easy.
12:33
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  President Obama will have only 30 minutes w/ Zardari and Karzai to engage them. Nonetheless, he will be driving home how mutually interdependent the fates of the countries are and that Islamist terrorism and insurgency now poses deep problems and challenges to both countries.
12:34
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  There have been some improvements in intelligence sharing and border cooperation between the two countries - not sufficient, but a positive development nonetheless. Unfortunately, Pakistan's attention is once again being drawn away toward the east & toward its own jihadist problem now.
12:34
[Comment From Adrianna (DC)]
Can the international community negotiate with a moderate Taliban?
12:34
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  The answer depends on the terms of negotiations and on a proper understanding of what the Taliban is and what can or cannot be understood as moderate Taliban.
12:36
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  Both on the Pakistan and Afghan sides, the Taliban(s) are  a conglomerate of various actors, including local antagonized  and disfranchised tribes.  Some of the inviduals as well as groupings also side with the Taliban because they believe that security wise this is less risky and than siding w/ the Afghan govenrment or NATO.  
12:37
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  We can and should engage such actors -- explore ways that we could reassure them and help address some of their local grievances. However, the purpose should not be used to turn them into Anbar-like militias, so -called lashkars.
12:37
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  The lashkar strategy has not worked well in Pakistan, and will be counterproductive in Afghanistan.
12:38
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  And we should not kid ourselves that we can have any strategic negotiations with the so-called Quetta shura, the hardcore Taliban around Mullah Omar.
12:38
[Comment From Donald G. Barnes]
How do you assess the “talibanization-process“ in Pakistan and what do you think are its consequences for the regional security?
12:39
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  Clearly, the influence of jihadi groups in Pakistan has been increasing dramatically. Many of such groups have existed in Pakistan for a long time, but over the seven years they have reached a great momentum and have posed very serious threat to the Pakistani state.
12:42
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  This is not simply the case with Tehrik-i-Taliban and Mullah Fazlullah's group - Pahstun dominated groups -- but even more worrisomely with jihadi Punjab groups, such as Lashkar--i-Taiba. One of the most worrisome developments   has been the increasing capacity of these groups to latch onto non-ideological grievances and cleavages, such as the semi-feudal system that Pakistan exists in, including in Punjab -- a deeply stratified society where access to land is highly limited for example.
12:43
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  And unfortunately, the Pakistani state -- the civilians and the military and the business community -- has been by and large deeply ineffective in addressing the massive problems, including Talibanization, that the country is facing. Many are still in deep denial about the depth of the problem - even despite the outrage over the Swat flogging and the jihadist expansion into Buner and Dir.
12:43
[Comment From Prof. Natividad Fernandez]
What is and should be the EU role in Afghanistan and Pakistan? In particular, do you think the EU could contribute with development aid and conducting state missions to Pakistan as a way of conflict prevention?
12:45
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  The EU should play a direct role in AF-PAK and indeed can play a constructive role. Unfortunately, despite the deployment of European forces to Afghanistan and EU's substantial contribution to econ aid in Afghanistan, EU is lacking a clear policy and in fact it is not certain whether it considers the region of vital importance to its national interests.
12:47
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  This is clearly unfortunately because Pakistani-based groups pose a serious terrorism problem for Europe as the London bombing and the jetliner attempt, for example, highlighted. EU engagement in Afghanistan is hampered by the lack of resources, national caveats, limited attention, and the desire to withdraw troops as soon as possible.
12:49
Vanda Felbab-Brown -  Nonetheless, the US should continuing exploring with EU how Europe can stay in Afghanistan, how it can expand its economic aid and military/police/governance training. And it is also important, that along with other actors, such as China and Saudi Arabia, the EU and the US continue stressing to Pakistan the importance of not rolling over in the face of the jihadist threats and undertake deep structural reforms. No doubt - a daunting undertaking for which Pakistan lacks resources and will.
12:49
[Comment From Mitch Potter]
Greetings from a Canadian journalist. I wanted to ask your thoughts about the fragility of Pakistan today. Journalist and author Ahmed Rashid sounded a desperate note yesterday in the Washpost, concluding that "Pakistan needs help today, tomorrow could be too late." Do you also see the situation in such critical terms?
    Page 1  Next >
 
Powered by: CoveritLive  Reader Information