Home | Live Now! |  Try it Now
Arena Live
 
2:56
Fred Barbash-Moderator -  Welcome to a real time conversation at POLITICO's arena.   Today it's all about the GOP, which had a busy weekend in the wake of the president's budget announcement, with congressional leaders (Eric Cantor, Paul Ryan) calling for a strategy of ideas and Rush Limbaugh, speaking at CPAC, calling for, well, something more militant.   As several contributors point out today, the two are not necessarily mutually exclusive. On the other hand, some see Limbaugh as a "gift to the Democrats," one that, as Tom Mann says, will keep on giving.

What do you think?


2:58
Fred Barbash-Moderator -  Let's begin with a post by Arena contributor Cesar Conda this morning: Rush Limbaugh's strategy of simply opposing President Obama's plans without offering any commonsense policy alternatives will doom the GOP to being the Party of the deep, Deep South, a couple of Plain States, talk radio, and the 150 "Inside-the-Beltway" conservatives who attend Grover Norquist's "Wednesday Meeting." By all means, Congressional Republicans should use every parliamentary tool available to stop Obama's proposed tax increases, which would be the largest in the history of the world. But they also must propose their own budget alternative, one that calls for pro-growth tax relief, cuts wasteful domestic spending, expands quality and affordable private health insurance coverage, and increases domestic energy production. Republicans should also put forth ideas to reform and improve entitlement programs, along the lines proposed by Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wisconsin). Finally, we need a compelling free-market policy agenda to address middle-class quality-of-life and cost-of-living concerns, and here are twelve specific ideas to get Republicans started.

Rush is a fantastic entertainer, and an important voice for conservative principles. But if I were a Republican officeholder or candidate, he probably would not be my first choice to execute my legislative strategy or run my campaign.

3:02
[Comment From Rick]
Completely overblown & stupid!
3:02
Fred Barbash-Moderator -  Arena contributor Stephen Walt: In case anyone hasn’t noticed, our country is facing serious challenges at home and abroad. Hoping that Obama fails, as Limbaugh has, merely exposes Limbaugh as the self-absorbed, faux-patriotic blowhard he’s always been. If he becomes the poster child for the GOP, the Democrats may be in power for decades. To seek new and better ideas, as Cantor and Gingrich propose, is precisely what the party out of power should do. It’s better for the country and will be better for the GOP’s long-term fortunes. Heck, if they come up with some ideas that make more sense than Obama’s (admittedly a tall order), maybe this recovering Republican will switch back.

3:03
Fred Barbash-Moderator -  Anyone who wants to participate--just write your name where it says "your name,' compose your thoughts and press SEND. Do use a name rather than a handle or "guest" please...thanks.
3:03
[Comment From Helen]
The Limbaugh/Steele sparring session will be humorous for about a day, or two.
3:04
Fred Barbash-Moderator -  Helen: And, do you mean, after a day or two it's no longer humorous, or that it will go away after a day or two?
3:05
[Comment From Ryan]
The GOP needs to get itself some leadership , organization and purpose. The good thing for the GOP is that Obama just got into office and they still have plenty of time to get it together!
3:07
[Comment From Helen]
Meaning that it is already boring. Who cares what Rush Limbaugh thinks?!?! He's a radio blowhard; his job and schtick is to stir the pot up.
3:08
[Comment From Christine Pelosi]
2 words: big tent. While President Obama was honoring his electoral mandate with a call for universal health care and the nomination of the red-state Democrat Kathleen Sebellius for HHS Secretary, Mitt Romney was winning the Limbaugh Primary for President, and Newt Gingrich was wooing voters in the New York Times with ideas that were soundly rejected by the voters in 2008. What to do? As discussed in mid-November 2008, [LINK: http://www.politico.com/arena/perm/Christine_Pelosi_9BA9E4CA-F538-4886-A0E2-527F8516D1C9.html] I think Republicans should follow our lead. No, I don't mean become Democrats (though you are welcome) - I mean do what we did: take the single step of finding one core principle you can all agree will be best for the country and stick to it. For the Democrats in 2005 facing the self-proclaimed "permanent Republican majority," it was preserving America's inter-generational social compact of Social Security by banding together in a big tent and stopping Bush's privatization efforts with one voice, setting the stage for further bottom-up consensus-building that led to the New Direction Agenda of 2006 and the Presidency in 2008. For the GOP, it could be one message on health care that springs from bottom-up consensus among Republicans, attracts Independents, and unites Americans. And for those moderates left behind by both Limbaugh and Gingrich and their screeds about abortion and socialism, come give Obama's big tent a try.
    Page 1  Next >
 
Powered by: CoveritLive  Reader Information