Home | Live Now! |  Try it Now
The Scouting Report: Delays in Closing Guantánamo Bay
 
12:18
Fred Barbash - moderator -  We're getting ready to start the chat   - please stay tuned
12:30
Fred Barbash - moderator -  

Hello and thanks for joining us. Today's topic: delays in closing the military detention facility at   Guantanamo Bay. With us to answer your questions is Brookings senior fellow Benjamin Wittes. Thanks for being here, Ben.

12:30
Benjamin Wittes -  Thanks for having me.
12:31
[Comment From Jason]
Do you think it was a mistake for President Obama to announce the closure of Guantanamo without addressing where current detainees would be transferred, as many in Congress have stated?
12:31
Benjamin Wittes -  

It was probably a mistake to announce a specific date for   the closure of Guantánamo without a detailed sense of how to handle the myriad issues the closure would necessarily raise. (Several of us were warning about the difficulty of the project early on.) That said, I don’t think it was a mistake to announce an intention to close the facility at the outset of the administration—and I think the deadline was a very forgivable error.

12:31
[Comment From Shawn]
Is it possible that Guantanamo Bay as a detention facility could remain open under different ground rules?
12:31
Benjamin Wittes -  

 

I think it’s pretty unlikely that Gitmo will remain open. Backing off the central promise to close it would be such a humiliating climb-down for the administration that I have to think the President’s people will do everything possible to make the closure happen. Whether it happens on time is a different matter.

12:32
[Comment From Erin]
Can you explain the current delays the Obama Administration faces in closing the military detention facility at Guantanamo?
12:32
Benjamin Wittes -  

The current delays have several distinct causes—all of them knowable and predictable in advance:

1)           Turns out it’s not so easy to resettle people one decides to release. Not a lot of countries are eager to resettle Guantánamo detainees, some of them cannot be sent to their home countries for fear of torture or other mistreatment, and Congress does not want them here.

2)           Figuring out how to bring to trial those you want to try for crimes is very hard.

3)           Nobody quite knows how to handle those the government does not believe it can put on trial (in either military commissions or federal courts) but also does not feel comfortable setting free.

12:33
[Comment From Mark Walker]
What is the estimated number of detainees that would still be facing trial if Guantanamo is closed in early 2010?
    Page 1  Next >
 
Powered by: CoveritLive  Reader Information