COVERITLIVE.COM

11:31

SarahKK - Hey guys ... we're going to get started with the chat pretty soon. In the meantime, you can start submitting questions or comments.

11:34

SarahKK -

And be heard! Vote in our poll above. :)

11:35

SarahKK - Or below, wherever it is on your screen (whoops).

11:43

SarahKK - We'll start the discussion for real right around noon, but keep the comments coming.

11:52

SarahKK - Oh, and my recap of last night, if you want to check it out, is here: http://weblogs.baltimoresun.com/entertainment/realitycheck/blog/2009/08/so_you_think_you_can_dance_final_4_perform.html

11:55

SarahKK - Thursday-morning quarterbacking myself, I feel like I'm on board with Nigel regarding Jeanine and Brandon edging out the other two last night, but we'll delve into the details a little more once we get started for real at noon. *waits impatiently*

11:58

SarahKK -

OK, we're getting started, 3, 2, 1 ...

11:58

[Comment From Kate ]
I will be very upset if Evan or Brandon win! Kayla and Jeanine are the better dancers overall, and a girl needs to win.

11:59

SarahKK - Interesting ... I think Kayla is really great technically, but she didn't really connect with the audience that well. She has the nice backstory of her grandparents sacrificing for her dance lessons (and they are adorable grandparents), but beyond that, she didn't really show her personality that much.

12:00

SarahKK - And on this show, that can be a weakness.

12:00

SarahKK - Love Evan as a person and love his style, but he's definitely out of his depth in this Top 4. But he shows that popularity and being charming also play a big role on SYTYCD.

12:01

Carla - Carla, here. Sometime-guest poster. I agree that it would be nice to see a girl win Season 5 -- hasn't only 1 woman won before?

12:01

SarahKK - Just Sabra, two seasons ago.

12:01

[Comment From John-John Williams IV ]
@ Kate: Are you serious?!?!?!? I'm all about gender rights, but we can't let that cloud our judgement!! Hands down, Brandon beats the girls in a dance-off! For real!!!

12:02

[Comment From Kate ]
NO BRANDON NO BRANDON!

12:02

[Comment From Kate ]
Brandon has a hot body and can flip, that's not dancing!

12:02

SarahKK - Kind of interesting that no one has voted for Kayla in our poll yet.

12:02

SarahKK - That;s not all Brandon does, Kate! Did you see his last two solos??

12:02

[Comment From John-John Williams IV ]
Carla!!! Come on!!! Same thing! yes it would be nice to have another woman win, but you can't deny Brandon's ability!!

12:03

SarahKK - OK, moving on (for now)

Page 1 Next >